Tools Are Not Strategies

   Each and every day there are new platforms, new tools, and emerging technologies designed to capture the all-elusive consumer in more engaging, entertaining, and less-invasive ways. Certainly we have witnessed game-changing, paradigm-shifting developments over the past few years that are so ubiquitous today, it’s hard to remember life before.

Recently, I’ve been in a series of strategy sessions and found the following items on various agendas:

  • Facebook strategy
  • Twitter strategy
  • Vine—try or not?
  • Mobile-first
  • App development
  • Instagram trial

And more! I’m sure you’ve found yourselves in similar meetings with items like these listed for discussion. What I’d like to assert however, is that such items should not be the focal point of a marketing initiative or strategy session. Why? They’re not strategies—they’re tools and tactics which should never be the basis of programming intended to address bigger business objectives.

Of course all of these tools have merit in some respect, but their merit comes as part of a larger picture. And the picture I find myself returning to is one that global management consulting firm, McKinsey & Company, developed and wrote about in their 2009 white paper entitled,The Consumer Decision Journey.

McKinsey points out that, “The decision-making process is a more circular journey, with four primary phases representing potential battlegrounds where marketers can win or lose.” We have to think about tools, trends and tactics within the context of this journey, not separate from it. Consumer behavior and thinking may have evolved but it still follows a path and the ways in which marketers engage consumers should be centered on that path and not on any one tool.

If after the moment of purchase, a brand encourages a consumer to “like” them on Facebook, that brand should have a Facebook approach that is post-purchase centric to encourage loyalty and repeat buying. If a brand encourages a consumer to “like” them on Facebook to get coupons and discounts, that brand should employ a Facebook strategy that is intended to move the consumer closer to the moment of purchase. If a brand chooses to deploy both, it runs the risk of alienating a portion of its Facebook audience and needs to reconsider how it might appeal to two distinct consumers at two different stages of engagement. Not easily done.

It’s not enough to simply say, “We need a Facebook strategy,” or “We want to be on Vine.” Marketers must evaluate how these tools can help move the consumer through the decision journey to support awareness, acquisition or loyalty. Start with the consumer, understanding how they travel to arrive at decisions regarding your product or brand. And while the tools you use can and will change, your strategy should not.

I recommend aligning various tools and platforms with phases of the journey. Map the purpose of each platform, detailing what it is supposed to accomplish as part of the decision-making process. If you can’t define where a platform lives, re-evaluate. If you have too many platforms in any one stage, re-evaluate. If you have gaps, re-evaluate. You don’t have to try every tool or seize every trend. You should only try those with the potential to migrate prospects to consumers and ultimately advocates within the context of the greater strategy.

Don’t focus on trends and lose sight of your goals. And don’t confuse tools with strategies. Do weigh in with your perspective as IHAF explores Tools & Trends this month through blog posts, tweets, and conversation within our members-only community on LinkedIn. Not an IHAF member? That an easy fix—join us!

Rebecca Garnick Ast is Vice President of Program Development at Tippingpoint Labs, a content marketing agency and IHAF member company. Tippingpoint Labs works with in-house agencies and corporate advertisers to focus their content efforts, develop efficiencies, and deliver results. Through tested frameworks and proven approaches, Tippingpoint Labs helps brands improve their processes and increase their effectiveness building awareness, acquisition, and loyalty.

Recent Posts

The Latest in Offshore Creative Production

February 17, 2020

  • by Shelley Harrison and Anil Noorani, Amnet

Tapping lower-cost, overseas resources for creative production is not a new trend. And as agencies look to decrease their production costs by 40% or more, offshore partnerships are transitioning from experimental to mainstream.

If your in-house agency has yet to engage in offshoring (or tried a …

Read Moreright arrow

What’s Your Purpose?

September 25, 2023

  • by IHAF Staff

Everyone needs a sense of purpose. Purpose provides direction. It helps us prioritize. And it brings much-needed meaning to daily tasks.

For in-house agencies, purpose is especially important because it helps us stay focused on the type of work we should be doing as opposed to being sidetracked by …

Read Moreright arrow